Research Programme

With a thematic focus on the formation of normative orders, the programme explores current conflicts over a just world order and their historical genesis from the perspective of different disciplines in the humanities and social sciences (philosophy, history, political science, legal studies, ethnology, economics, religious studies and sociology). In contrast to functionalist explanatory approaches which always appeal to factors external to norms and have their own scientific justification, the Cluster is concerned with the internal conflicts, processes and procedures involved in the formation of normative orders. Normative orders serve to justify claims to validity and the claims to political authority, and to a particular distribution of goods and life chances, based upon them. They are embedded in justification narratives which emerge within unique historical constellations in response to a specific pressure of problems. For the most part they are handed down, modified, institutionalized and put into practice over long periods of time. At the same time, however, every traditional justification narrative points beyond the facticity of an extant order and thus presents opportunities for criticism, rejection or resistance. It is this performative tension between narratives and claims to justification which renders the conflictual dynamic of the formation and transformation of normative orders intelligible.

The researchers participating in the Cluster of Excellence find their common ground in this internal standpoint. The use it to investigate the formation of normative orders, employing the resources of their own disciplines, while engaging in reflexive communication concerning this shared foundation. Without absolutizing the distinction between internal and external perspectives on the formation of normative orders, one can nevertheless observe in current conflicts how people give immediate expression to their experiences of injustice – with all of the attendant ambivalences, especially when these expressions are quickly broadcast across the globe by the mass media in a way that was previously unknown. Individual and collective experiences of injustice, of contempt, humiliation and lack of respect for one’s dignity, are heightened into normative claims aimed at different audiences with different reasons, if necessary also with violence. Thus we can at present only conjecture what conflicts over just normative orders will be triggered by the predicted change in the global climate, what distribution conflicts over increasingly scarce essential resources in the more seriously affected regions and what social and cultural struggles will be triggered once the predicted mass migrations to the more favourable climatic zones begin.

Those affected pay no attention to functional differentiations within global social systems or to semantic and institutional differences between law, morality and religion. While people are acting and speaking, they are certainly also anonymous points of intersection of systems of social communication and of unconscious symbolic systems – mere tokens in a strategic game over markets for raw materials and consumer goods or the mouthpieces of particular group interests who are instrumentalized by the mass media. Our aim is not to lull the humanities and the social sciences back into an anthropological slumber and to orient them to an image of human beings that denies their contextual character and tries to pass itself off as a transcendental a priori. However, we regard factual expressions of outrage over injustices – regardless of how justified, one-sided, selective or distorted they may be in particular cases – as sufficient to raise the question of how a theory of the formation of normative orders that goes beyond the dichotomy between action theory and structural or systems theory is possible today, a theory which, given the global challenges, avoids the quietism of structural theory as much as the alarmism of a theory of action


Headlines

Normen im Streit - Perspektiven aus Recht, Philosophie und Internationalen Beziehungen


Prof. Dr. Nicole Deitelhoff, Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst und Prof. Dr. Christoph Möllers führen die Podiumsdiskussion "Normen im Streit - Perspektiven aus Recht, Philosophie und Internationalen Beziehungen" am 29. September 2017 um 18.00 Uhr im Gebäude "Normative Ordnungen". Es moderiert Dr. Lisbeth Zimmermann. Mehr...

Forschungsbau "Normative Ordnungen" auf dem Campus Westend

Upcoming Events

27 September 2017, 7pm

Lecture within the Summer School "Finanzsystem und Gesellschaft": Inequality and the Wealth Management Profession. Brooke Harrington (Professor of Economic Sociology, Copenhagen Business School). Comment: Jan Pieter Krahnen (Professor of Finance; House of Finance, Goethe-Universität). More...

28. September 2017

Karrierekonferenz für (Post-)Doktorandinnen: Kurswechsel. Mehr...

29 September 2017, 6pm

Panel Discussion: Normen im Streit - Perspektiven aus Recht, Philosophie und Internationalen Beziehungen. Prof. Dr. Nicole Deitelhoff (Director Peace Research Institute Frankurt - Member of the Leibniz Association, Principal Investigator Cluster of Excellence "The Formation of Normative Orders", Professorin für Internationale Beziehungen und Theorien globaler Ordnungen Goethe-University Frankfurt), Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst (Co-Director Cluster of Excellence "The Formation of Normative Orders" and Professor für Politische Theorie und Philosophie Goethe-University) and Prof. Dr. Christoph Möllers (Professor für Öffentliches Recht und Rechtsphilosophie an der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin). Moderation: Dr. Lisbeth Zimmermann. More...

Latest Media

Criminal Law and the Promise of Self-Government

Malcolm Thorburn
Lecture Series "Criminal Justice between Purity and Pluralism - Strafrechtspflege zwischen Purismus und Pluralität"

A Critical Theory of Transnational Justice: One Ground and Several Contexts

Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst
Frankfurt Summer Academy on Global Justice

New full-text Publications

Szews, Johann (2017):

Zahlungsmoral: Überlegungen zum Zusammenhang von Schuld und Schulden mit Nietzsche, Weber und Bourdieu, Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2017. More...

Forst, Rainer (2017):

The Justification of Basic Rights: A Discourse-Theoretical Approach. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2017. More...