Self-interest vs. the Common Good: On a Central Issue in Economic Ethics

The supposed conflict between individual self-interest and the common good is one of the hottest debated issues in economic ethics, environmental ethics as well as at the intersection between ecology and economics.
Examples concerning planet earth ecology include air and water pollution, overfishing, the clearing of rain forest for agriculture, animal habit destruction, the over-exploitation of natural resources especially in so called ‘Third World’-countries, carbon emissions and the burning of fossil fuels/non-renewable energy resources and consequential global warming and climate change (i.e., ecological footprint).
From an economics perspective we have to debate the role of privilege- and rent seeking special interest groups, the phenomena of lobbyism and corruption, corporate scandals, the role of hedge funds, private equity, derivatives, investment-banking, gambling/speculation on the stock-exchange, insider-dealings, market manipulation, the alleged ‘greed’, avarice, and other forms of unethical behavior as well as the near-sightedness of (some) managers and the short-term oriented incentive systems of shareholder-value capitalism (e.g. bonus payments, thinking in quarterly periods; short-term economy), etc. – all seeming at odds with the broader and long-term interests of other legitimate stakeholder-groups like customers, suppliers, employees and the general public. All these phenomena may be summarized under the heading tragedy of the commons given their lack of economic, social and environmental sustainability.
This research project has been analyzing potential trade-offs and compatibilities between self-interest and common welfare. Both norms play a key role in economic theory as well as for the development and implementation of new concepts for economic policy and regulation.
The project is especially interested in the respective narratives that are used to justify the two norms. Because such narratives typically have their origin beyond economics in the narrow sense, the interdisciplinary framework of the Cluster is an ideal setting for studying the genesis and development of these norms in close collaboration with related disciplines.
The clash of different and differently motivated normative concepts, the emerging conflicts of interest and trade-offs as well as possible solutions were studied from a conceptual point of view as well as in the light of two case studies. One case is the emergence and implementation of the Equator Principles, a voluntary Corporate Social Responsibility initiative in the banking industry; the other case concerns the pros and cons of a paternalistic economic policy.
Standard economic theory postulates that “laissez faire” leads to results that satisfy self-interest and common welfare at the same time. As was elaborated in the project, this view is the result of a particular narrative that only emerges in early modern times and has always been confronted with other views from within and outside economics, in particular ethics, which point out the conflicting nature of both norms. The project showed both at the conceptual level and in the discussion of the two case studies that appropriate mechanisms of regulation, monitoring and sanctions are needed in order to make the results of economic behavior compatible with both norms. In the implementation of those mechanisms and interventions the danger of paternalism needs to be addressed if it is to be avoided.

The most important events of this project:

Workshop: Behavioral Business Ethics: Verhaltensökonomische und ordnungsethische Perspektiven, first “Frankfurt-Workshop on business ethics”, Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, October 1–2, 2013 (in cooperation with the Center for Business Ethics, Gerhard Minnameier).

Workshop: 10 Years Equator Principles (2003–2013): Fragment of a Normative Sustainability Order or Business as Usual?, Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, March 14–15, 2013.

 

The most important publications of this project:

Martens, W./Linden, B.v.d./Wörsdörfer, M.: “Deliberative Democracy and the Equator Principles Framework: How to Assess the Democratic Qualities of a Multi-Stakeholder Initiative from a Habermasian Perspective?”, in: Journal of Business Ethics 141, 2017, pp. 1–19.

Klump, Rainer and Manuel Wörsdörfer: “Paternalist Economic Policies. Foundations, Implications and Critical Evaluations”, in: Ordo Yearbook of Economic and Social Order 66, 2015, pp. 27–60.

Wörsdörfer, Manuel: “Equator Principles: Bridging the Gap between Economics and Ethics?”, in: Business and Society Review 120(2), 2015, pp. 205–243.

Wörsdörfer, Manuel: “Inside the ‘Homo Oeconomicus Brain': Towards a Reform of the Economics Curriculum?”, in: Journal of Business Ethics Education 11, 2014, pp. 5–40.

Wörsdörfer, Manuel: “Free, Prior, and Informed Consent’ and Inclusion: Nussbaum, Ostrom, Sen and the Equator Principles Framework”, in: Transnational Legal Theory 5(3), 2014, pp. 464–488.

 

 

People in this project:

  • Project director / contact
  • Project members
    • Wörsdörfer, Manuel, PD Dr. (former member) | Profile


Publications of this project:

  • Open-Access-Logo Klump, Rainer; Pilz, Lars (2018): Durch Eigennutz zum Gemeinwohl: Individualisierung, Reformation und der „Geist des Kapitalismus“. Zur Entstehung und Bedeutung von Leonhard Fronspergers Schrift „Von dem Lob deß Eigen Nutzen“ aus dem Jahre 1564. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2018
    Details | Link to full text | urn:nbn:de:hebis:30:3-473730
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2017): The Equator Principles and the ‘Business and Human Rights Debate’: Hype or Hope? in: Tomasic, Roman/De Jonge, Alice (eds.): Research Handbook on Transnational Corporations; Edward Elgar, pp. 139-168.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2016): Die Äquator-Prinzipien und die ‘Business and Human Rights’-Debatte in: Wendt, Karen (ed.): CSR und Investment Banking. Investment und Banking zwischen Krise und Positive Impact; Berlin, Gabler; 405-425.
    Details
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2016): Selbstselektion versus ‚Indoktrination‘ in der (sozialen) Marktwirtschaft: Eine wirtschaftsethische Bestandsaufnahme in: Minnameier, Gerhard (ed.): Ethik und Beruf: Interdisziplinäre Zugänge; W. Bertelsmann Verlag; S. 135-156.
    Details
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): Animal Behavioral Economics: Lessons Learnt from Primate Research; Economic Thought 4(1); 80-106.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): A New Understanding of Economic Behavior, Organizations and Regulation – Foundations, Options and Challenges; Habilitation thesis, Frankfurt.
    Details
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): Equator Principles – Now and Then in: Schwartz, Michael/Harris, Howard (eds.): Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations (Vol. 14): The Ethical Contribution of Organizations to Society; Emerald; 121-160.
    Details
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): 10 years Equator Principles: A critical appraisal in: K. Wendt (ed.): Responsible Investment Banking. Risk Management Frameworks and Softlaw Standards; Cham, Springer; 473-501.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): Equator Principles: Bridging the Gap between Economics and Ethics?; Business and Society Review 120(2); 205-243.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): Human Rights Due Diligence und die Äquatorprinzipien; WestEnd. Neue Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung 01-2015; 95-109.
    Details
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2015): The Equator Principles and Human Rights Due Diligence – Towards a Positive and Leverage-based Concept of Corporate Social Responsibility; Philosophy of Management 14(3); 193-218.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel; Klump, Rainer (2015): Paternalist Economic Policies. Foundations, Implications and Critical Evaluations; Ordo Yearbook of Economic and Social Order 66; 27-60.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel; Hennig, Alicia (2015): Challenging Voluntary CSR-Initiatives – A Case Study on the Effectiveness of the Equator Principles; Working Paper Series of the Cluster of Excellence ‘The Formation of Normative Orders’ 01/2015.
    Details | Link to full text | urn:nbn:de:hebis:30:3-381320
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2014): The ‘Societal Crisis of the Present’ as a Neoliberal Leitmotif; History of Economic Thought and Policy 2/2014; 77-109.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2014): Freiburg School of Law and Economics, Freiburg (Lehrstuhl-) Tradition and the Genesis of Norms; i-lex 21; 211-256.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2014): Inside the ‘Homo oeconomicus Brain’: Towards a Reform of the Economics Curriculum?; Journal of Business Ethics Education 11; 5-40.  
    Details | Link to full text
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2014): ‘Free, Prior, and Informed Consent’ and Inclusion: Nussbaum, Ostrom, Sen and the Equator Principles Framework; Transnational Legal Theory 5(3); 464-488.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Klump, Rainer (2013): Wirtschaftspolitik. Instrumente, Ziele und Institutionen; München, Pearson.
    Details
  • Open-Access-Logo Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2013): 10 Years ‘Equator Principles’: A Critical Economic-Ethical Analysis; Osgoode Hall Law School, Comparative Research in Law & Political Economy (CLPE) Research Paper Series; Research Paper No. 54/2013.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2013): Von Hayek and Ordoliberalism on Justice; Journal of the History of Economic Thought 35(3); 291-317.
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wörsdörfer, Manuel (2013): Individual and Regulatory Ethics: An Economic-Ethical and Theoretical-Historical Analysis of Ordoliberalism in: OEconomia. History, Methodology, Philosophy 3(4); 523-557.
    Details | Link to full text


Headlines

Denken im Widerspruch

Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst, Co-Sprecher des Exzellenzclusters "Die Herausbildung normativer Ordnungen" zum Gedenken an Theodor W. Adorno aus Anlass seines 50. Todestags. Mehr...

„Noch einmal: Zum Verhältnis von Moralität und Sittlichkeit" - Vortrag von Jürgen Habermas am 19. Juni 2019. Skript und Aufzeichnung verfügbar

Die Meldung zum Vortrag finden Sie: Hier...
Weitere Informationen (Videoaufzeichnung, Skript und Medienecho) finden Sie: Hier...

"The History of Postmetaphysical Philosophy and the Future of Democracy" - Konferenz zu Ehren von Jürgen Habermas

Am 20. und 21. Juni fand am Exzellenzcluster "Die Herausbildung normativer Ordnungen" die Konferenz "The History of Postmetaphysical Philosophy and the Future of Democracy" statt.
Die Meldung zur Konferenz finden Sie hier...
Das Programm und weitere Informationen finden Sie hier...

Upcoming Events

20 August 2019, 7 pm

Goethe Lectures Offenbach: Prof. Dr. Klaus Günther: Wie frei sind wir im digitalen Echoraum? More...

9. September 2019, 11 Uhr

Workshop: Lehrbücher der Zukunft Mehr...

11. und 12. September 2019

Conference: Contextual Thinking in Economics. More...

-----------------------------------------

Latest Media

„Die gesellschaftlichen Voraussetzungen des Faschismus dauern fort“ Zur Aktualität Adornos

Podiumsdiskussion

Verzerrt das Kino die KI? Ein Gespräch über Privatheit, IT-Vertrauen und Repräsentation anhand von The Circle

Vinzenz Hediger im Gespräch mit Christoph Burchard
Talking About a Revolution: Rechtswissenschaft und Filmwissenschaft im Gespräch über künstliche Intelligenz und Kino

New full-text Publications

Kettemann, Matthias; Kleinwächter, Wolfgang; Senges, Max (2018):

The Time is Right for Europe to Take the Lead in Global Internet Governance. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2018. More...

Kettemann, Matthias (2019):

Die normative Ordnung der Cyber-Sicherheit: zum Potenzial von Cyber-Sicherheitsnormen. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2019. More...