Publication details

'Professionals of International Justice. From the Shadow of State Diplomacy to the Pull of the Market of Commercial Arbitration', in André Nollkaemper, Jean d’Aspremont, Wouter Werner and Tarcisio Gazzini (eds.), International Law as a Profession, Cambridge University Press, pp. 311-337.

Book chapter

Author(s): Dezalay, Sara; Dezalay, Yves
Year of publication: 2017

Abstract: The growth of high stakes disputes between corporations and states has triggered a surge of interest for the professionals of international justice: the ‘club’ of international arbitrators or the ‘invisible college’ of the International court of justice (ICJ). Scholarly accounts on these professional practices tend to reinforce the fragmentation of international law into distinct poles - public international justice before the ICJ, and private international justice before institutions like the World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) or the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA). These formulations obfuscate the growing convergence between these two poles of international justice. This papers looks specifically at professional circulations: its cue is that far from being a side phenomenon, the professional assets accumulated collectively by the agents invested in international justice contribute to shaping the potential markets as much as the social credibility of transnational forms of dispute management. It argues, further, that these dynamics of circulation follow a pull of the market of private international justice. Its research strategy, based on biographical interviews and a database of over 400 profiles, underlines the inter-connectedness between the different institutions and professional arenas of international justice. Recalling first the common genesis of public and private international justice at the turn of the twentieth century, it explores their revivals in the 1980s: the symbolic boom of the ICJ contrasts with the market burst of international commercial arbitration. The flexibility of this form of ‘offshore litigation’ enabled its expansion towards high stake disputes between states and corporations from the 1990s. Mounting attacks against the legitimacy of the ICSID illustrate what the second part describes as a growth crisis: leaning on the symbolic authority of agents of public international justice has reinforced the dynamic of the market of private international justice through a pull that is transforming both poles of justice. This is further illustrated with the revival of the PCA from the 2000s, as a new node of exchange between public and private international justice epitomizing a displacement of the centre of gravity of the field of international justice as a whole.

Keywords: Sociology of international law; Treaty investment arbitration; ICSID; International Court of Justice

Subject(s): sociology

Back to publications list


Denken im Widerspruch

Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst, Co-Sprecher des Exzellenzclusters "Die Herausbildung normativer Ordnungen" zum Gedenken an Theodor W. Adorno aus Anlass seines 50. Todestags. Mehr...

„Noch einmal: Zum Verhältnis von Moralität und Sittlichkeit" - Vortrag von Jürgen Habermas am 19. Juni 2019. Skript und Aufzeichnung verfügbar

Die Meldung zum Vortrag finden Sie: Hier...
Weitere Informationen (Videoaufzeichnung, Skript und Medienecho) finden Sie: Hier...

"The History of Postmetaphysical Philosophy and the Future of Democracy" - Konferenz zu Ehren von Jürgen Habermas

Am 20. und 21. Juni fand am Exzellenzcluster "Die Herausbildung normativer Ordnungen" die Konferenz "The History of Postmetaphysical Philosophy and the Future of Democracy" statt.
Die Meldung zur Konferenz finden Sie hier...
Das Programm und weitere Informationen finden Sie hier...

Upcoming Events

9. September 2019, 11 Uhr

Workshop: Lehrbücher der Zukunft Mehr...

11. und 12. September 2019

Conference: Contextual Thinking in Economics. More...


Latest Media

„Die gesellschaftlichen Voraussetzungen des Faschismus dauern fort“ Zur Aktualität Adornos


Wie frei sind wir im digitalen Echoraum?

Prof. Dr. Klaus Günther
Goethe Lecutres Offenbach

New full-text Publications

Burchard, Christoph (2019):

Künstliche Intelligenz als Ende des Strafrechts? Zur algorithmischen Transformation der Gesellschaft. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2019. More...

Kettemann, Matthias (2019):

Die normative Ordnung der Cyber-Sicherheit: zum Potenzial von Cyber-Sicherheitsnormen. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2019. More...