Transformation of Normative Orders: The Transnationalization of Rule and Resistance

The continuing process of globalization leads not only to denser international and transnational relations, but also to more pronounced dissent to global regulatory politics. This is evidenced in resistance to liberal economic models, disregard for international rules and open protest against ‘western values’. This could be related to the deepening penetration of international institutions and norms into national jurisdictions and the increasingly drastic adaptations they demand of state and non-state actors. Such forms of political resistance have not yet seen systematic treatment in International Relations because they defy the realist, liberal and constructivist paradigms’ attempts to explain them satisfactorily. Only a perspective that enables the normative and institutional forms of global politics to be understood as a form of rule can grasp and explain forms of resistance, opposition and radical dissidence, as a socially and normatively relevant phenomenon.

This project addresses the question of the relationship between rule and resistance at the transnational level. A central hypothesis is that the more transnational rule finds expression in domination and suppresses or curtails opportunities for participation and criticism, the more willing critical actors are to organize themselves at the transnational level to enhance the effectiveness of their resistance. A second, complementary hypothesis is that, in order to assert themselves, political orders must confront transnational agents of resistance and to this end must strengthen their international cooperation. Transnational rule is in this sense a response to the political challenge facing a normative order.

Two empirical studies were developed to test these hypotheses. One study analyzed the development of transnational networks linking security organizations, in particular the police, in response to the transnationalization of protest. The second study, by contrast, took the transnational networks and forms of cooperation of resistance (in particular, exit forms of resistance in ecovillages) as a starting point for establishing the extent of the transnationalization of governance structures and the forms they assume. The studies analyzed how far the two transnationalization processes influence each other (reinforcing/inhibiting/no influence). The two studies were able to show that the transnationalization of rule and resistance are closely interconnected. Forms of governance are becoming transnationalized in response to a corresponding transnationalization of resistance; and resistance is increasingly forming against transnational institutions and practices the more the latter are equipped with authority. This fundamental correlation was also confirmed in several workshops and conferences conducted by the project. In this context, however, it also becomes apparent that the mechanisms responsible for this diverge sharply between different forms of rule and resistance.

Both studies are approaching completion and some of their central results have already been published in, among others, a project volume published by Springer in January 2017. In addition, the research project has established a working paper series (international dissidence) of its own in which research results generated within the project and in the context of the project were published continuously. Furthermore, in spring 2017, the research project organized a major international conference at which the central research results were presented and which served, in addition to international publications, also the preparation of follow-up projects.

The most important publications of this project:

Daase, Christopher/Nicole Deitelhoff/Ben Kamis /Jannik Pfister/Philip Wallmeier (eds.): Herrschaft in den internationalen Beziehungen, Wiesbaden: Springer, 2017.

Pfister, Jannik: "Diesseits des Transnationalen. Die Verräumlichung widerständiger Praktiken von der Alterglobalisierungsbewegung bis Occupy“, in: K. H. Backhaus and David Roth-Isigkeit (eds.): Praktiken der Kritik, Frankfurt am Main: Campus, 2016, pp. 157–183.

Daase, Christopher and Nicole Deitelhoff: "Jenseits der Anarchie: Widerstand und Herrschaft im internationalen System“, in: Politische Vierteljahresschrift 56(2), 2015, pp. 299–318.

Wallmeier, Philip: "Dissidenz als Lebensform. Nicht-antagonistischer Widerstand in Öko-Dörfern“, in: Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft (Sonderband II), 2015, pp. 181–200.

Deitelhoff, Nicole: "Leere Versprechungen? Deliberation und Opposition im Kontext transnationaler Legitimitätspolitik“, in: A. Geis/F. Nullmeier/C. Daase (eds.): Der Aufstieg der Legimititätspolitik, (Leviathan Sonderband 27), Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2012, pp. 63–82.


People in this project:

  • Project director / contact
    • Daase, Christopher, Prof. Dr. | Profile
    • Deitelhoff, Nicole, Prof. Dr. | Profile
  • Project members
    • Kamis, Ben, MSc. I.R. (former member) | Profile
    • Pfister, Jannik (former member) | Profile
    • Wallmeier, Philip (former member) | Profile

Publications of this project:

  • Wallmeier, Philip (i.E.): Trumps organisierte Verantwortungslosigkeit - Ein Deutungsvorschlag zur Krise der liberalen Weltordnung aus der Perspektive der Kritischen Theorie, in: Daase, Christopher und Kroll, Stefan, Hrsg., Angriff auf die liberale Weltordnung – U.S. Außen- und Sicherheitspolitik unter Trump, Springer VS.
  • Deitelhoff, Nicole; Daase, Christopher; Witt, Antonia (2019): Beyond Anarchy. Rule and Resistance in World Politics, i.V.
  • Daase, Christopher; Deitelhoff, Nicole; Kamis, Ben; Pfister, Jannik; Wallmeier, Philip (2017): "Die Herrschaftsproblematik in den Internationalen Beziehungen – eine Einleitung", in: Herrschaft in den Internationalen Beziehungen, Springer VS, S. 1-26.
  • Daase, Christopher; Deitelhoff, Nicole; Kamis, Ben; Pfister, Jannik; Wallmeier, Philip (Hrsg.) (2017): Herrschaft in den internationalen Beziehungen, Wiesbaden: SpringerVS
  • Pfister, Jannik (2017): Protest Policing als transnationale bürokratische Herrschaft, in Christopher Daase/ Nicole Deitelhoff/ Ben Kamis/ Jannik Pfister/ Philip Wallmeier (Hrsg.): Herrschaft in den internationalen Beziehungen, Wiesbaden: SpringerVS, 2017, S. 95-118.
  • Deitelhoff, Nicole; Daphi, Priska (2017): Protest im Wandel? Jenseits von Transnationalisierung und Entpolitisierung, in: Deitelhoff, Nicole/Daphi, Priska/Rucht, Dieter/Teune, Simon (Hrsg.): Protest und Bewegungen im Wandel? Sonderheft Leviathan, Baden-Baden: Nomos, i.E.
  • Deitelhoff, Nicole; Daphi, Priska; Rucht, Dieter; Teune, Simon (2017): Protest und Bewegungen im Wandel? Sonderheft Leviathan, Baden-Baden: Nomos, i.E.
  • Pfister, Jannik (2016): Diesseits des Transnationalen: Die Verräumlichung widerständiger Praktiken von der Alterglobalisierungsbewegung bis Occupy, in Katia Backhaus/ David Roth-Isigkeit (Hg.): Praktiken der Kritik. Normative Orders Bd. 17, Frankfurt: Campus, S. 157–183.
  • Daase, Christopher (2015): Die Innenpolitik der Außenpolitik. Eine Bilanz der Außen- und Sicherheitspolitik der schwarz-gelben Koalition 2009-2013. In: Zohlnhöfer, Reimut/Saalfeld, Thomas (Hrsg.): Politik im Schatten der Krise. Eine Bilanz der Regierung Merkel 2009-2013. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, 555-580
  • Daase, Christopher (2015): On Paradox and Pathologies: A Cultural Approach to Security. In: Junk, Julian/Schlag, Gabriele & Christopher Daase (Hrsg.): Transformations of Security Studies. Dialogues and Discipline. London/New York: Routledge, 82-93
  • Daase, Christopher; Fehl, Caroline; Geis, Anna; Kolliarakis, Georgios (2015): Recognition in International Relations. Rethinking a Political Concept in a Global Context. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan
  • Daase, Christopher; Deitelhoff, Nicole (2015): Jenseits der Anarchie: Widerstand und Herrschaft im internationalen System, in: Politische Vierteljahresschrift 56: 2, 299-318.
  • Daase, Christopher; Engbert, Stefan; Renner, Judith (2015): Guilt, Apology and Recognition in International Relations. In: Daase, Christopher/Engert, Stefan/Horelt, Michael-André/Renner, Judith/Strassner, Renate (Hgg.): Apology and Reconciliation in International Relations: The Importance of Being Sorry. London/New York: Routledge, 1-28.
  • Kamis, Ben; Pfister, Jannik; Wallmeier, Philip (2015): The Constitution of Rule in Political Spaces beyond the Nation-State, Internationale Dissidenz Working Paper #1/2015
    Details | Link to full text
  • Wallmeier, Philip (2015): Dissidenz als Lebensform. Nicht-antagonistischer Widerstand in Öko-Dörfern, Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft, Sonderband 2015 II, S. 181-200
  • Deitelhoff, Nicole; Daase, Christopher (2015): Herrschaftszeiten. Internationale Politische Theorie als Gesellschaftstheorie der internationalen Beziehungen, in: Zeitschrift für Politische Theorie, Jg. 6, Heft 2/2015, S. 141–158.
  • Daase, Christopher; Deitelhoff, Nicole (2014): Zur Rekonstruktion globaler Herrschaft aus dem Widerstand, Internationale Dissidenz Working Paper #1/2014
    Details | Link to full text


"Making Crises Visible" - Ausstellung und Rahmenprogramm beginnen im Februar 2020

Der Forschungsverbund "Normative Ordnungen" der Goethe-Universität beteiligt sich von Februar bis Juni 2020 am Rahmenprogramm zum wissenschaftlich-künstlerischen Projekt "Making Crises Visible". Mehr...

DFG fördert Kolleg-Forschungsgruppe „Polyzentrik und Pluralität vormoderner Christentümer“

Eine von der DFG geförderte Kolleg-Forschungsgruppe mit dem Titel  „Polyzentrik und Pluralität vormoderner Christentümer“ richtet ab Oktober 2020 den Blick auf frühere Formen des Christentums. Sprecherinnen sind Prof. Dr. Birgit Emich und Prof. Dr. Dorothea Weltecke, Mitglied des Forschungsverbunds "Normative Ordnungen" der Goethe-Universität. Mehr...

Upcoming Events

27. Februar 2020, 10 Uhr

Workshop: Criticism of Religion in the Enlightment Era. Mehr...

5. bis 6. März 2020

1st Meeting of the International Doing IPS Working Group: Doing International Political Sociology!?. Mehr...

5. und 6. März 2020

XIX. Walter Hallstein-Kolloquium: 70 Years of Human Rights and the Rule of Law. More...


Latest Media

Demokratie_Was wird aus der Krise des Politischen?

Prof. Dr. Martin Saar
Denkraum "Zukunft_Aber wie?"

Entzauberung und Wieder-Verzauberung in Ruinenlandschaften: Jia Zhangkes experimentelles chinesisches Großstadtkino

Winnie Yee
Lecture & Film "Jia Zhangke: Kino der Transformation"

New full-text Publications

Burchard, Christoph (2019):

Künstliche Intelligenz als Ende des Strafrechts? Zur algorithmischen Transformation der Gesellschaft. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2019. More...

Kettemann, Matthias (2019):

Die normative Ordnung der Cyber-Sicherheit: zum Potenzial von Cyber-Sicherheitsnormen. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2019. More...