A Kantian account of political obligation in crisis situations

Dr. Sofie Møller

Laufzeit des Forschungsprojekts 12/2017 – 12/2021

The question of the foundation and limits of political obligation is much debated in contemporary political theory. Political obligation is understood not merely as a duty to obey the law, but as a wider reaching duty to promote and further a political community. While many contemporary political theorists take a Kantian approach to its foundation, they reject Kant’s absolute account of political obligation; unlike Kant, contemporary accounts allow the suspension of obligation in situations of crisis. Some scholars have argued that a Kantian conception of political obligation can be amended with an account of the limits of this obligation (Stilz 2009). Against this view, others have argued that the problem of determining the boundaries of political obligation in a Kantian conception is a fatal flow which gives us reason to abandon the Kantian approach altogether (Simmons 2013). However, while scholars agree that an account of the foundation of political obligation should include the possibility to suspend this obligation in crisis situations, this suspension is conceived as an exception rather than an integrated property of obligation. But if we conceive of political obligation as an exception, then no clear rules for this exception are provided and the evaluation of when to suspend political obligation is left to the judgment of the individual citizen.
In place of this ad hoc approach, this project revisits Kant’s account of political obligation to provide a contemporary Kantian account of its suspension in situations of crisis which includes parameters for the limits of political obligation. The aim is to provide a Kantian account which assigns limits to political obligation which are inherent to the account rather than arbitrarily imposed.

References in the text

Kant, Immanuel. Kant’s gesammelte Schriften. Berlin: De Gruyter, 1900-.
Simmons, J.A. (2013): Democratic Authority and the Boundary Problem. Ratio Juris 26, no. 3, pp. 326–357.
Stilz, A. (2009): Liberal Loyalty: Freedom, Obligation, and the State. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Selected publications related to this project

Møller, Sofie (forthcoming): “The Politics of Reason”. In: A. Pinheiro Walla and M. R. Demiray (eds.): Reason, Rights and Law: New Essays on Kantian Philosophy, University of Wales Press.
Møller, Sofie (2013): “The Court of Reason in Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason.” Kant-Studien 104 (3), 301–20.
Møller, Sofie (2013): “Human Rights Jurisprudence Seen through the Framework of Kant’s Legal Metaphors.” In: Reidar Maliks and Andreas Føllesdal (ed.): Kantian Theory and Human Rights, London: Routledge, 52–69.


Headlines

"Making Crises Visible" - Ausstellung und Rahmenprogramm beginnen im Februar 2020

Der Forschungsverbund "Normative Ordnungen" der Goethe-Universität beteiligt sich von Februar bis Juni 2020 am Rahmenprogramm zum wissenschaftlich-künstlerischen Projekt "Making Crises Visible". Mehr...

DFG fördert Kolleg-Forschungsgruppe „Polyzentrik und Pluralität vormoderner Christentümer“

Eine von der DFG geförderte Kolleg-Forschungsgruppe mit dem Titel  „Polyzentrik und Pluralität vormoderner Christentümer“ richtet ab Oktober 2020 den Blick auf frühere Formen des Christentums. Sprecherinnen sind Prof. Dr. Birgit Emich und Prof. Dr. Dorothea Weltecke, Mitglied des Forschungsverbunds "Normative Ordnungen" der Goethe-Universität. Mehr...

Upcoming Events

31. Januar 2020, 9 Uhr

Workshop: Miteinander reden oder aneinander vorbei? Chancen und Herausforderungen aus der Praxis der Wissenschaftskommunikation. Mehr...

31. Januar 2020, 18 Uhr

Podiumsdiskussion: Kritik der Vernunft oder Vernunft der Kritik? Mehr...

3. Februar 2020, 18.15 Uhr

Interdisziplinäre Vortragsreihe "Evidenz in der Wissenschaft": Prof. Dr. Hartmut Leppin: Hat Jesus eigentlich gelebt? Zur Frage der historischen Evidenz. Mehr...

-----------------------------------------

Latest Media

Der Zorn der Moralisten und die Theorie des Ressentiments. Vortrag von Prof. Albrecht Koschorke am 20. Januar 2020

Prof. Albrecht Koschorke
Lecture


Autorschaft und Hypermedialität in PLATFORM

Cecília Mello
Lecture & Film "Jia Zhangke: Kino der Transformation"

New full-text Publications

Burchard, Christoph (2019):

Künstliche Intelligenz als Ende des Strafrechts? Zur algorithmischen Transformation der Gesellschaft. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2019. More...

Kettemann, Matthias (2019):

Die normative Ordnung der Cyber-Sicherheit: zum Potenzial von Cyber-Sicherheitsnormen. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2019. More...