The Normativity of Formal Knowledge: The Exact Sciences, Equality and Situated Universalism in the 18th Century

The project aims to deepen our understanding of the interaction between formal knowledge and the formulation of normative positions in the European Enlightenment. It provides a new translation of and commentary on the major philosophical text of one of its main representatives, Jean D’Alembert, namely, his Essay on the Elements of Philosophy, first published in 1759. Besides the translation and commentary of the text itself, the project includes three analytical essays which explore the context and focus the “scientific,” the “moral” and the “epistemological” position(s) of D’Alembert. Since it is characteristic of Enlightenment thinkers to combine science and morals, philosophy and politics, our goal is to highlight the specific form of interaction between D’Alembert’s reflections on the mathematical and physical sciences and his epistemological views and moral considerations. For example, when he discusses which kinds of knowledge are capable of certainty, he not only defines knowledge and certainty but also denies that religious and metaphysical arguments on matters of scientific or moral relevance have any claim to validity. For D’Alembert, in fact, morals is a science with a high epistemological status in need of further exploration and expansion. Thus he combines certain knowledge with reflections about the socio-political order, arguing, for example, that the anthropological law of self-preservation of a being dependent on others entails a radical policy of redistribution of wealth as long as luxury and poverty coexist within a single socio-political order.  

Since the research project focuses on the interaction between epistemological and moral (or political) positions, it fits well with the Cluster’s research on the historical development of varieties of normativity. The project thus provides historical input into the discussion of central concepts of the Cluster, such as equality and justice. Furthermore, it provides a prime example of the discursive strategies of (radical) Enlightenment explored during the Ancien Régime to provoke a change – a change in the way of thinking both about nature and society and, ultimately, about how to govern. It exemplifies how changes of normative orders are prepared in contexts which at first sight may appear to be non-political, such as the epistemological discussion of the order(s) of knowledge.

Our translation and commentary of the Essay was produced in collaboration with the French research network “Groupe D’Alembert” (CNRS/ Académie des sciences). On a number of occasions we exchanged working knowledge through meetings in Paris, Lyon, Montpellier, Göttingen and Marseille. In the course of these meetings we were able to recruit a member of the French team, Christophe Schmit, for a month’s stay in Frankfurt as a fellow of the Cluster. Schmit will contribute commentaries on several chapters and an introductory essay on the epistemology of the physical sciences. Alexandre Guilbaud, who provides the commentary on one chapter of the essay, was also recruited during these meetings. The core work on the project was performed by Dagmar Comtesse who completed her PhD in political philosophy in 2014. In addition, our bi-lingual student assistant Céline Volders provided extremely competent and reliable help in revising the translations of D’Alembert and of the contributions of the French colleagues.

The translation and commentary were completed during the second period of the research project. The principal thesis was confirmed that there is a strong interaction between D’Alembert’s epistemological positions on formal sciences and his conception of a moral science. At present this is being extended into a new research project aiming at a study of the political philosophy (or philosophies) of the Encyclopédie. The correspondences between formal sciences and moral science in D’Alembert’s thought were put to the test by Moritz Epple in several talks and publications focusing on the notion of “equality.”

The results of the project were presented by Dagmar Comtesse at the Congress of the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Philosophie (DGPhil), September 2014 in Münster. The title of her presentation was: „Die Politische Philosophie der Encyclopédie“ (“The Political Philosophy of the Encyclopédie”). In October 2017 Dagmar Comtesse will present further results at the international conference on occassion of the 300-years anniversary of D’Alembert at the Université Montpellier. The title of her presentation is: „D’Alembert dans les débats de son temps“.

The most important publications of this project:

Comtesse, Dagmar and Moritz Epple: Jean D’Alembert: Versuch über die Elemente der Philosophie, forthcoming.

Comtesse, Dagmar and Moritz Epple: "Between Appropriation and Rejection: Translating D’Alembert into German”, and “D’Alembert on Translation", in: A. Guilbaud/C. Schmit (eds.): Tercentenary of Jean Le Rond D’Alembert’s Birth (1717–1783). A Review of the Latest Research, Special Issue of the Journal Centaurus, forthcoming.

Comtesse, Dagmar: “Religion, Religionskritik, Zivilreligion und Revolution”, in: Franziska Flügel-Martinsen (ed.): Staatsverständnisse in Frankreich, Baden-Baden: Nomos, forthcoming.

*Epple, Moritz: “Ulikhet, grenser og alliansen mellom de lærde og de store: Utidssvarende betraktninger fra en encyclopedist“, in: ARR – Idéhistorisk Tidsskrift 4, 2015, (= Liv, Arr, idéhistorie: Festtidskrift til Espen Schaanning), 2015, pp. 27–49.

Epple, Moritz and Dagmar Comtesse: “Auf dem Weg zu einer Revolution des Geistes? Jean d’Alembert als Testfall", in: A. Fahrmeir and A. Imhausen (eds.): Die Vielfalt normativer Ordnungen: Konflikte und Dynamik in historischer und ethnologischer Perspektive, Frankfurt am Main: Campus, 2013, pp. 21–47.



People in this project:

  • Project members
    • Comtesse, Dagmar, Dr. (former member) | Profile

Publications of this project:

  • Comtesse, Dagmar (2017): „Rousseaus religion civile als Ausdruck seiner radikaldemokratischen Volkssouveränität“, Europeana 9, Universität Jiao Tong Shanghai/ Paris: L'Harmattan, S. 89-107.
  • Comtesse, Dagmar (2015): „Frederick Neuhouser: Rousseau's Critique of Inequality, Cambridge University Press 2014”, Rezension, Constellations, September 2015, S. 475-476.
  • Open-Access-Logo Comtesse, Dagmar (2015): Taming the superlative, embedding the comparative: a form of subjectivation for a post growth society. Working Paper Series of the Cluster of Excellence ‘The Formation of Normative Orders’ 02/2015.
    Details | Link to full text | urn:nbn:de:hebis:30:3-386473
  • Epple, Moritz (2015): Ulikhet, grenser og alliansen mellom de lærde og de store: Utidssvarende betraktninger fra en encyclopedist. ARR – Idéhistorisk Tidsskrift 4 (2015), (= Liv, Arr, idéhistorie: Festtidskrift til Espen Schaanning), S. 27-49.
  • Comtesse, Dagmar (2014): „Das Böse“ in : Thomas M. Schmidt/Annette Pitschmann (Hg.), Religion und Säkularisierung. Ein interdisziplinäres Handbuch, Metzler Verlag, S. 173-179


„Normative Ordnungen“, herausgegeben von Rainer Forst und Klaus Günther, ist im Suhrkamp Verlag erschienen

Am 17. April 2021 ist der Sammelband „Normative Ordnungen“ im Suhrkamp Verlag erschienen. Herausgegeben von den Clustersprechern Prof. Rainer Forst und Prof. Klaus Günther, bietet das Werk einen weit gefassten interdispziplinären Überblick über die Ergebnisse eines erfolgreichen wissenschaftlichen Projekts. Mehr...

Das Postdoc-Programm des Forschungsverbunds „Normative Ordnungen“: Nachwuchsförderung zwischen 2017 und 2020

Die Förderung des wissenschaftlichen Nachwuchses ist seit je her ein integraler Bestandteil des Forschungsverbunds „Normative Ordnungen“. Das 2017 neu strukturierte, verbundseigene Postdoc-Programm bietet die besten Bedingungen zu forschen und hochqualifizierte junge Wissenschaftler*innen zu fördern. Zum Erfahrungsbericht: Hier...

„Symposium on Jürgen Habermas’ Auch eine Geschichte der Philosophie“ herausgegeben von Rainer Forst erschienen

Als jüngste Ausgabe der Zeitschrift "Constellations: An International Journal of Critical and Democratic Theory" ist kürzlich das „Symposium on Jürgen Habermas, Auch eine Geschichte der Philosophie“ herausgegeben von Prof. Rainer Forst erschienen. Mehr...

Upcoming Events

2. Dezember 2021, 19.30 Uhr

DenkArt "Identität_Aber welche?": Dr. Emilia Roig (Politologin): Identitäsraub_Wer darf über wen sprechen?. Mehr...

7. Dezember 2021, 18.00 Uhr

Virtuelle Ringvorlesung "Algorithmen und die Transformation von Demokratie": Prof. Dr. Sofia Ranchordas (Universität Groningen/LUISS Universität Rom, Professor of Public Law): Empathy in the Digital Administrative State. Mehr...


Latest Media


Weitere Videoaufzeichnungen finden Sie hier...

Identitätspolitik_Was soll das denn sein?

Prof. Dr. Stephan Lessenich (Institut für Sozialforschung, Goethe-Universität)
Moderation: Rebecca Caroline Schmidt (Forschungsverbund Normative Ordnungen der Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main)
DenkArt "Identität_Aber welche?"

„It‘s complicated“ - Zur Beziehung von algorithmischen Entscheidungen und demokratischem Rechtsstaat

Prof. Dr. Emanuel V. Towfigh (EBS Universität, Professor für Öffentliches Recht, Empirische Rechtsforschung und Rechtsökonomik)
Ringvorlesung "Algorithmen und die Transformation von Demokratie"

New full-text Publications

Rainer Forst (2021):

Solidarity: concept, conceptions, and contexts. Normative Orders Working Paper 02/2021. More...

Annette Imhausen (2021):

Sciences and normative orders: perspectives from the earliest sciences. Normative Orders Working Paper 01/2021. More...